CanYouTellFakeNewsFromReal_StudyFindsStudentsHaveDismayingInability_TheTwo-Way_NPR.pdf
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 1/18
HOURLY NEWS
LISTEN LIVE
PLAYLIST
AMERICA
DONATE
The Two-Way
Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability To Tell Fake News From Real, Study Finds November 23, 2016 · 12:44 PM ET
CAMILA DOMONOSKE
Stanford researchers assessed students from middle school to college and found they struggled to distinguish ads from articles, neutral sources from biased ones and fake accounts from real ones.
Gary Waters/Ikon Images/Getty Images
KPBS Radio On Air Now
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 2/18
If the children are the future, the future might be very ill-informed.
That’s one implication of a new study from Stanford researchers that evaluated
students’ ability to assess information sources and described the results as
“dismaying,” “bleak” and “[a] threat to democracy.”
As content creators and social media platforms grapple with the fake news crisis, the
study highlights the other side of the equation: What it looks like when readers are
duped.
The researchers at Stanford’s Graduate School of Education have spent more than a
year evaluating how well students across the country can evaluate online sources of
information.
Middle school, high school and college students in 12 states were asked to evaluate the
information presented in tweets, comments and articles. More than 7,800 student
responses were collected.
In exercise after exercise, the researchers were “shocked” — their word, not ours — by
how many students failed to effectively evaluate the credibility of that information.
The students displayed a “stunning and dismaying consistency” in their responses, the
researchers wrote, getting duped again and again. They weren’t looking for high-level
analysis of data but just a “reasonable bar” of, for instance, telling fake accounts from
real ones, activist groups from neutral sources and ads from articles.
“More than 80 percent of middle schoolers believed that ‘sponsored content’ was a real news story.
“Many assume that because young people are fluent in social media they are equally
savvy about what they find there,” the researchers wrote. “Our work shows the
ALL TECH CONSIDERED
Fake Or Real? How To Self-Check The News And Get The Facts
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 3/18
opposite.”
A professional appearance and polished “About” section could easily persuade
students that a site was neutral and authoritative, the study found, and young people
tended to credulously accept information as presented even without supporting
evidence or citations.
The research was divided by age group and used 15 different assessments. Here’s a
sample of some of the results:
Most middle school students can’t tell native ads from articles.
The researchers showed hundreds of middle schoolers a Slate home page that included
a traditional ad and a “native ad” — a paid story branded as “sponsored content” — as
well as Slate articles.
Most students could identify the traditional ad, but more than 80 percent of them
believed that the “sponsored content” article was a real news story.
“Some students even mentioned that it was sponsored content but still believed that it
was a news article,” the researchers wrote, suggesting the students don’t know what
“sponsored content” means.
Most high school students accept photographs as presented, without
verifying them.
The researchers showed high school students a photograph of strange-looking flowers,
posted on the image hosting site Imgur by a user named
“pleasegoogleShakerAamerpleasegoogleDavidKelly. The caption read “Fukushima
Nuclear Flowers: Not much more to say, this is what happens when flowers get nuclear
birth defects.”
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 4/18
pleasegoogleShakerAamerpleasegoogleDavidKelly Share
1 / 2Fukushima Nuclear Flowers
39 32 23,750
Sam Wineburg, a professor of education and history at Stanford University and the
lead author of the study, spoke to NPR on Tuesday.
“The photograph had no attribution. There was nothing that indicated that it was from
anywhere,” he said. “We asked students, ‘Does this photograph provide proof that the
kind of nuclear disaster caused these aberrations in nature?’ And we found that over
80 percent of the high school students that we gave this to had an extremely difficult
time making that determination.
“They didn’t ask where it came from. They didn’t verify it. They simply accepted the
picture as fact.”
Many high school students couldn’t tell a real and fake news source apart
on Facebook.
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 5/18
“ Sam Wineburg, lead author of the study
They didn’t ask where it came from. They didn’t verify it. They simply accepted the picture as fact.
One assessment presented two posts announcing Donald Trump’s candidacy for
president — one from the actual Fox News account, with a blue checkmark indicating
it was verified, and one from an account that looked like Fox News.
“Only a quarter of the students recognized and explained the significance of the blue
checkmark, a Stanford press release noted. “And over 30 percent of students argued
that the fake account was more trustworthy.”
Most college students didn’t suspect potential bias in a tweet from an
activist group.
The researchers sent undergraduate students a link to a tweet by MoveOn about gun
owners’ feelings on background checks, citing a survey by Public Policy Polling.
MoveOn @MoveOn
New polling shows the @NRA is out of touch with gun owners and their own members ampr.gs/1Pyw4qg #NRAfail
74 5:20 PM – Nov 17, 2015
96 people are talking about this
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 6/18
They asked students to evaluate the tweet and say why it might or might not be a good
data source.
“More than 30 percent of students thought a fake Fox News account was more trustworthy than the real one.
“Only a few students noted that the tweet was based on a poll conducted by a
professional polling firm,” which might make it a good source, the researchers wrote.
At the same time, less than a third of students cited the political agenda of
MoveOn.org as a reason it might be a flawed source.
And more than half of the students didn’t even click on the link within the tweet before
evaluating the usefulness of the data.
Most Stanford students couldn’t identify the difference between a
mainstream and fringe source.
The American Academy of Pediatrics, which publishes the journal Pediatrics, has
more than 65,000 members and has been around since 1930.
“Less than a third of students thought MoveOn.org has a political agenda that might justify skepticism about its data on gun owners.
The American College of Pediatricians (ACPeds) split from AAP in 2002, over
objections to parenting by same-sex couples. ACPeds claims homosexuality is linked to
pedophilia. It’s classified as a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center, which
estimates that ACPeds has about 200 members.
In an article in Education Week, Wineburg and his colleague Sarah McGrew explain
that they directed Stanford undergrads to articles on both organizations’ sites. The
students spent up to 10 minutes evaluating them, and were free to click links or Google
anything they liked.
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 7/18
“More than half concluded that the article from the American College of Pediatricians
… was ‘more reliable,’ ” the researchers wrote. “Even students who preferred the entry
from the American Academy of Pediatrics never uncovered the differences between
the two groups.”
You can see in-depth examples of some of the exercises — including sample responses
— at the study’s executive summary.
The project began before the recent uproar over the prevalence of fake news online.
But its relevance is immediately clear.
Wineburg told NPR on Tuesday that the study demonstrates that U.S. classrooms
haven’t caught up to the way information is influencing kids daily.
“What we see is a rash of fake news going on that people pass on without thinking,” he
said. “And we really can’t blame young people because we’ve never taught them to do
otherwise.”
In fact, as Wineburg and McGrew wrote in Education Week, some schools have filters
directing students to valid sources, which doesn’t give them practice learning to
evaluate sources for themselves.
The solution, they write, is to teach students — or, really, all Internet users — to read
like fact checkers.
That means not just reading “vertically,” on a single page or source, but looking for
other sources — as well as not taking “About” pages as evidence of neutrality, and not
assuming Google ranks results by reliability.
“The kinds of duties that used to be the responsibility of editors, of librarians now fall
on the shoulders of anyone who uses a screen to become informed about the world,”
Wineburg told NPR. “And so the response is not to take away these rights from
ordinary citizens but to teach them how to thoughtfully engage in information seeking
and evaluating in a cacophonous democracy.”
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 8/18
You keep vital information flowing. Support this critical public service by donating to your local NPR station.
DONATE NOW
More Stories From NPR
NEWS Last ‘Two-Way’ Post Isn’t Our Last Story: A Look Back, And How To Find Us Now
LISTEN: Sam Wineburg Explains Study’s ‘Bleak’ Results
LISTEN · 4:14 PLAYLIST Download
fake news
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 9/18
y y ,
ARTS & LIFE Kennedy Center Unveils Progress On New Extension For Artistic Projects
TECHNOLOGY S.C. Mom Says Baby Monitor Was Hacked; Experts Say Many Devices Are Vulnerable
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 10/18
SPORTS Former USA Gymnastics CEO Told Staff To Keep Alleged Abuse Quiet, Waited To Tell FBI
WORLD U.S.-Led Coalition Accused Of ‘Potential War Crimes’ In Push To Reclaim Raqqa
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 11/18
NATIONAL Voters Recall Aaron Persky, Judge Who Sentenced Brock Turner
Popular on NPR.org
ECONOMY Bitter Taste For Coffee Shop Owner, As New $600 Jobless Benefit Drove Her To Close
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 12/18
INVESTIGATIONS Company With Ties To Trump Receives Millions From Small Business Loan Program
POLITICS DOJ Would Support Legal Action If Governors’ Restrictions Go ‘Too Far,’ Barr Says
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 13/18
HEALTH What Happens If U.S. Reopens Too Fast? Documents Show Federal Coronavirus Projections
HEALTH Tracking The Pandemic: How Quickly Is The Coronavirus Spreading State By State?
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 14/18
POLITICS Trump Says He’ll Suspend Immigration For 60 Days Over Coronavirus Fears
NPR Editors’ Picks
HEALTH NY Governor Andrew Cuomo Says President Trump Promised Help With Coronavirus Testing
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 15/18
Testing
POLITICS National Security Adviser O’Brien Alleges WHO Is ‘Propaganda Tool For The Chinese’
NATIONAL Why You May Get An Email About COVID-19 From The Census Bureau
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 16/18
HEALTH After The ICU, Many COVID-19 Survivors Face A Long Recovery
AUTHOR INTERVIEWS ‘I’m Living In The World With No Secrets,’ Says Trans Activist Jennifer Finney Boylan
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 17/18
BUSINESS Data Of Nearly 8,000 Small Businesses May Have Been Exposed, SBA Says
The Two-Way
READ & LISTEN
Home
News
Arts & Life
Music
Podcasts
Programs
CONNECT
Newsletters
Contact
Help
ABOUT NPR
Overview
Finances
People
Press
Public Editor
Corrections
GET INVOLVED
Support Public Radio
Sponsor NPR
NPR Careers
NPR Shop
NPR Events
Visit NPR
2020/4/21 Can You Tell Fake News From Real? Study Finds Students Have ‘Dismaying’ Inability : The Two-Way : NPR
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/23/503129818/study-finds-students-have-dismaying-inability-to-tell-fake-news-from-real 18/18
terms of use
privacy
your privacy choices
text only
© 2020 npr